中文  |  ENGLISH

As Concentrated Solar Power bids fall to record lows, prices seen diverging between different regions

2018.02.20     From: CSP Today

As CSP bids keep falling, there will likely be a growing price divergence between projects in countries such as Chile and the UAE at the lower end of the scale, and the likes of the United States at the other end.


Auction results suggest CSP will generate power at a levelized cost of electricity (LCOE) of $60/MWh to $100/MWh by 2020, the International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA) estimates. IRENA says CSP prices will fall at a rate of 30% for every doubling of cumulative installed capacity from 2010-2020, compared to a learning rate of 35% for solar PV, 21% for onshore wind, and 14% for offshore wind.


These figures only tell part of the story. As Jonathan Walters, leader of the Middle East and North Africa CSP Knowledge and Innovation Program, noted to CSP Today, 2017 saw bids as low as $73/MWh in Dubai, $63/MWh in Australia, and less than $50/MWh in Chile.


On the other hand, Craig Turchi, a senior engineer and researcher specializing in CSP at the US National Renewable Energy Laboratory, revealed to CSP Today that NREL expects CSP prices in the US to stand at about $100/MWh in 2020. NREL suspects “lower labor costs and favourable financial terms” are responsible for much of the differences between its own estimates and those prices being reported in other countries, Turchi said.


Walters and other leading industry consultants have often spoken of the advantages concessional financing gives to countries that are eligible for these types of investments, including the UAE, Morocco, and Jordan.


Scale, stability, and solar resource


As CEO of Solar Reserve, the company which submitted the (unsuccessful) sub-$50 bid in Chile and the (successful) $63/MWh bid in Australia, Kevin Smith is well-placed to comment on the reasons for these record-low CSP prices. He named four factors: labor costs; size, in which projects with multiple towers afford economies of scale; solar resource, where the higher direct normal irradiance in places such as Chile’s Atacama desert helps to more efficiently capture and convert sunlight into energy; and economic and political stability, where eliminating currency risk makes debt and equity financing less expensive.


“The real story is scale,” Walters argued, explaining that monopolies benefitting from fixed feed-in tariffs had historically prevented the attainment of economies of scale. Now that ACWA Power’s 700 MW Dubai Electricity and Water Authority project is single-handedly increasing global installed CSP capacity by 14%, and with China planning to add the equivalent of the current 5 GW global capacity by 2020, Walters said economies of scale will kick in to further reduce costs.


As CSP bids fall to record lows, a price gap is seen emerging between projects in the US and Chile (Image: CSP Today Projects Tracker)


New technologies are another pathway to cost reductions, and the fact that some of these technologies only appear in a handful of projects makes it difficult to produce reliable cost estimates for the entire industry, Turchi argued. For example, he noted that the salt-tower design is still in “a phase of rapid learning and optimization,” and that there are still only a few plants built around towers, compared to dozens built around parabolic troughs. He said NREL expects costs for salt-tower plants to decline as solar fields become more standardized, and as constructers and investors become more familiar with the technology.


Turchi and SolarReserve’s Smith both nominated thermal storage systems as the technology best placed to drive cost reductions. Smith said costs would fall as developers learn from projects built with energy storage, as research and development continues, and as economies of scale are made possible by increased manufacturing of storage systems.


CSP and PV complementary rather than combative


Given that solar PV enjoys a superior learning rate and that some PV projects are selling energy at an LCOE of $20/MWh to $30/MWh, it is difficult not to draw comparisons between the two solar technologies.


Panelists at CSP Seville 2017 noted that PV has 80 GW in global installations, compared to just 5 GW for CSP – giving PV an obvious cost advantage. Smith pointed out that PV has utilized high-volume panel manufacturing in Asia (primarily China) – an advantage CSP cannot replicate.


Working against PV, Smith said, is that the energy storage issue has not been resolved and will increasingly challenge electrical distribution systems as PV penetration increases globally. “Curtailment issues and ability to meet shifting peak demand are becoming increasingly critical in California, China, and other global markets with high solar penetration. These issues are reducing the future value of renewables without storage.”


Ultimately, as Walters said, “CSP and PV are not really substitutes for each other any more than a three-course meal and a snack are substitutes. CSP and PV are actually complementary. PV by day and stored CSP by night can give you very cheap 24-hour solar energy.”


Smith said: “It is important to keep in mind that these CSP-with-energy storage projects are delivering both energy generation and energy storage, at a combined price. Thus, a more accurate cost comparison would be to evaluate CSP with energy storage versus PV plus batteries, or PV plus natural gas peaking plants that are required to back up intermittent generation during cloudy periods and peak usage hours in the evening.”


Relevant CSP Conference:2018 CSP Focus Conference(March 22-23 Beijing)

Leave your thoughts here

Free Reports

See more+
  • Dubai 950MW NOOR Energy 1 CSP+PV Project

    The $4.4 billion Noor Energy 1 solar thermal project will be the world’s largest CSP plant and includes a 100 MW CSP tower plant, three 200 MW parabolic trough CSP systems, 250 MW of PV capacity and 15 hours of molten salt CSP storage capacity.

  • China Large-scale CSP Projects Update

    Updating--Jan., 2020 Edition24 pagesPart 1: Background and Fact Sheet (P1-11) · Implementation and adjustment of 1st batch of CSP demonstrations· FiT policy update and prediction· Sum-up on the 20 projects technology, location, ownership and key participants Part 2: Milestones of Ch

  • Suppliers List of China Key CSP Projects (Updating)

    13 key concentrated solar power projects in China undergoing:Shouhang Dunhuang 100MW Molten Salt Parabolic Trough ProjectRoyal Tech Yumen 50MW Parabolic Trough ProjectDCTC Dunhuang 50MW MS CLFR ProjectRayspower Yumen 50MW Trough ProjectCNNC Royal Tech Urad 100MW Parabolic Trough ProjectSupcon Delingha 50MW Molten Salt Tower ProjectLuNeng Haixi 50 MW Solar Thermal Tower Plant ProjectPower C

  • Construction and Operation of SUPCON SOLAR Delingha 50MW Tower CSP Project

    40 pages in totalCompany Profile (P3-4)Construction of Delingha 50MW Tower CSP Project (P6-17)Operation of Delingha 50MW Tower CSP Project (P18-30)Issues during Commissioning and Operation (P31-39)

Upcoming Events

See more+

Project Updates

See more+

CONTACT US

Tex:+86-21-6111 0177

Email:csp@cspfocus.cn


备案/许可证编号为:沪ICP备17051021号

Wechat public platform

Follow CSP Focus for more news